Rivalry Brews is now Brew Pigeon. New name. Still great Ohio beers delivered.

Best Oktoberfest Beer: Ohio

At the official Oktoberfest celebration in Munich, you’ll find exactly six breweries represented. The dominance of these core beer brands does not allow for new entries to the competition. This international event is rich in German heritage and local traditions.

Ohio has its own legacy of German immigrants settling within its boarders, and Oktoberfest festivals are found throughout the buckeye state. In that spirit, Ohio breweries represent Oktoberfest beer with their own unique brands and brews.

Best Oktoberfest Beer: Ohio

Top Ohio Oktoberfest Craft Beers – BrewPigeon.com

The team of beer connoisseurs at BrewPigeon.com have spoken, and named their selections to the list of 2021 Best Oktoberfest Beer In Ohio. This collection of rich malt ales are represented in the Oktoberfest 2021 Craft Beer Box.

The company is currently accepting pre-orders for their collection of Ohio’s Best Oktoberfest & Pumpkin Craft Beers. The custom craft beer box is neatly packaged with fresh product, properly sealed and protected, and available to be direct shipped to fulfill online orders.


Our Top 2021 Lineup

The 2021 Oktoberfest collection includes 12 Ohio craft beers from Brew Pigeon's select partners, including several “top rated” breweries. The scheduled line-up for this year’s craft beer boxes include:

“We have really high-end quality beers that we sell to our customers,” said Peter Krafcik, BrewPigeon.com CFO and a passionate member of the company’s “taste team”. “I love beer, that’s not a hard thing for me to give my opinion on.”

“The big thing they (BrewPigeon.com users) talk about is the quality of the beer,” Peter added. These are beers that they will be writing about on forums on UnTappd, on Drizly, on beer forums, on Facebook… We are kind of their one-stop shop for a lot of these craft beers which they otherwise would not have access to.”

Inside Our Craft Beer Collection

The Blue Heron Brewery of Medina, Ohio brings its own “Oktoberfest” to the 2021 Brew Pigeon collection. Brew master Mike Piazza’s German-style Oktoberfest is expected to turn some heads this fall. Nestled in Austin Badger Park, this brewery and event center offer an inviting outing for Medina County locals. But it’s the taste of “Oktober” that fans will appreciate.

“Blue Heron makes some of the best underrated beers I’ve had,” Krafcik said. “They’re in Medina too, which is also good for us because we’re from Medina.”

Best Oktoberfest Beer Ohio - Twin Oast - Fretboard Breweries

For fans of this Blue Ash, Ohio-based legacy, it’s all about the bands and the brews. Fretboard Brewing offers year-round entertainment sporting the brand “Music To My Beers”. Their list of craft brews are classified as Year-Round Chart Toppers or Seasonal & One Hit Wonders. Rockin’ The Rheinis a toasted biscuit and balanced sweet malt Oktoberfest lager Cincy-area connoisseurs have come to enjoy.

In the words of the team at Ignite Brewing Company, “we have scoured the patch to find the perfect match.” This Barberton, Ohio brewery and taproom represents its seasonal brews with “Ignite The Jack-O-Lantern”.  Head Brewer Jason Porter and team boast a passion for making a difference in their community. The company’s brand pays homage to the Diamond Match Company founded nearby in 1880. But it’s their Oktober Ale which will ignite your taste buds this fall.

  • Pumpcan Spiced Ale
    - MadTree Brewing

Head brewer Ryan Blevins describes his Pumpcan Spiced Ale” as “all the flavors of your favorite pumpkin pie without the pumpkin.” MadTree Brewing’s fall craft beer incorporates cinnamon, nutmeg, and molasses into a rich 7.9% ABV boozy ale. The Cincinnati-based firm supports many local organizations with donations and scholarships. And yes, MadTree even coordinates a tree planting program. Nothing says fall like a delicious spiced ale.

  • Haunted Hayride Pumpkin Ale
    - Masthead Brewing Co.

First on our list to incorporate a spooky theme is Masthead Brewing Co. of Cleveland. Their “Haunted Hayride Pumpkin Ale” is self-described as a pumpkin / yam beer, incorporating cinnamon, nutmeg, and ginger. Listed on the National Registry of Historic Places, the brewery was once an auto dealership. It now sports a 100-foot bar, 300-seat taproom, and a Neapolitan-style pizza kitchen.

Best Oktoberfest Beer: Ohio - Saucy Brew Works - Ignite Breweries

Brew master Eric Anderson adds his German style Oktoberfest to the Saucy list of seasonal favorites. Saucy Brew Works has taken their brand and achieved rapid growth with three Cleveland area brewpub and coffeehouses, adding Columbus and Detroit to the mix. Festbier is described as a traditional-style brew, with a medium light body, and bold carbonation. Saucy’s brews are always a favorite of Brew Pigeon fans.

“It’s always an exciting time when you have one of the largest up and coming breweries in the state,” Krafcik said. “Brett Zimmerman… is a very determined, very smart guy in the industry. It’s really exciting that… these breweries are looking as our product and saying – “you guys know what you’re doing – we want to partner with you.”

The team at Twin Oast Brewing is a strong partner with BrewPigeon.com, and their popular flight of beers are consistently ordered. When the fall season begins, brew masters release their custom Proast, a Marzen-style German lager. The Port Clinton-based facility is located on a 60-acre farm estate, and is a destination stop for Ohio craft brew fans. Our 2021 Best Oktoberfest beer collection wouldn’t be proper without this Lake Erie islands institution.

“The beer’s fantastic. Fortunately for us, we get to deliver it,” Krafcik added. “It’s such a unique experience when you go there (the Twin Oast brewery). That’s also want makes it stand out.”



Other Craft Beer From


Brew Pigeon



Today, BrewPigeon.com represents nearly 30 custom craft breweries throughout Ohio, and ships to customers in 41 states. In the past 12-month period (August 2020 – July 2021), the online platform served 18,340 user sessions. While Ohio remains its strongest market (yes, Ohioans love Ohio craft beer!), Pennsylvania, Michigan, California, and Virginia round out the top five in total traffic.

In addition to the Oktoberfest collection, Brew Pigeon offers several customer package and gift options:

Close (esc)


Use this popup to embed a mailing list sign up form. Alternatively use it as a simple call to action with a link to a product or a page.

Age verification

By clicking enter you are verifying that you 21+ years old and will not be purchasing alcohol for anyone under 21 years old.


Your cart is currently empty.
Shop now